19 AGs support Wisconsin Catholic Charities case
February 4, 2025

Lake Country Tribune

(The Center Square) – Nineteen state attorneys general have joined Wisconsin’s Catholic Charities Bureau of Superior in challenging a Wisconsin Supreme Court ruling that the charity does primarily secular work and thus must pay into the state’s unemployment fund.

Catholic Charities appealed the Wisconsin court decision to the U.S. Supreme Court and the group of 19 state attorneys general filed an amicus brief in support of the group’s case.

“If any religious activity, no matter how deeply rooted in doctrine and practice, becomes secular the moment the nonreligious adopt it, then no religious exercise is safe from government regulation,” the attorneys general wrote.

The amicus brief was led by Ohio Attorney General Dave Yost and joined by Alabama, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Carolina, South Dakota, Utah, Virginia and West Virginia.

The Catholic Charities claim the Wisconsin ruling violates the First Amendment and it questions the Catholic church’s religious teachings.

“Catholic Charities Bureau answers Christ’s call to minister to the most vulnerable by caring for the poor, disabled, and elderly throughout the diocese and beyond,” said Bishop James Powers, Bishop of the Diocese of Superior. “We pray the Court recognizes that this vital work of improving the human condition lies at the heart of our duty as Catholics.”

Other briefs were filed by the U.S. Department of Justice, religious scholars, liberty law scholars and religious groups.

Non-profits that operate in Wisconsin for primarily religious purposes do not have to pay into unemployment in the state but the court ruled that the exemption does not apply to Catholic Charities because it serves everyone, not just Catholics.

“The power to define religion is the power to destroy it,” Yost said. “Our Constitution guards against government interference on religion, and few maneuvers are as intrusive as the government taking it upon itself to define religious practice.”

View More Sports Articles

The DockHounds Opening Weekend Recap

The DockHounds Opening Weekend Recap

The DockHounds' season has officially begun, as of Friday, May 9. The team played their first game of 2025 in Rosemont, Illinois at Impact Field against Illinois rivals the Chicago Dogs. The opening game served as a great start to the year, with the DockHounds...

Why Pickleball Has Become so Popular

Why Pickleball Has Become so Popular

Pickleball, a quirky hybrid of tennis, badminton, and ping-pong, has exploded in popularity over the past decade. From neighborhood courts to professional tournaments, this paddle sport is capturing hearts worldwide. But what’s driving its meteoric rise? Let’s break...

DockHounds Prepare for Their Own Opening Day

DockHounds Prepare for Their Own Opening Day

Last Thursday, March 27 marked the opening day for Major League Baseball, and on Monday, March 31 Wisconsin's very own Milwaukee Brewers hosted their home opener at American Family Field. Although the Brewers have been off to a brief but bad start so far this season,...