Two Men Accused in Sussex Bank Robbery
July 15, 2024

Lake Country Tribune

SUSSEX, Wis. – Two Milwaukee men with a history of serving federal prison time together are now accused in a Sussex bank robbery that took place on Tuesday, July 9, according to Fox 6.

Prosecutors allege that 30-year-old Jules Bahler robbed the bank while 38-year-old Shane Tillman acted as the getaway driver. Police responded to a bank on Main Street near Sussex Road shortly after noon. According to the criminal complaint, a teller reported that a man initially inquired about opening an account.

Shortly after, the same man returned to the teller’s window, passing a note that read, “This is a robbery, give me all the money.” The teller stated that the man threatened to shoot, though no weapon was visible.

The suspect left with between $4,000 and $5,000.

RELATED: They’re Back: Lac La Belle Historic Boat Tours Are Returning

The robbery was recorded on the bank’s surveillance cameras, allowing detectives to identify Bahler as the suspect. The getaway vehicle, a pickup truck, was also captured on video. Investigators used various camera footage to track down the truck’s license plate, which was co-registered in Tillman’s name.

Police apprehended Tillman at a Milwaukee motel where he was residing. During an interview with detectives, Tillman admitted to driving the pickup truck during the robbery but claimed he believed Bahler was planning to “pass a bad check.” Tillman stated it wasn’t until Bahler returned to the truck that he realized a robbery had occurred, at which point they fled the scene.

Tillman made his initial court appearance on July 12, where his cash bond was set at $250,000. The investigation and charges highlight the serious nature of the crime and the efforts by law enforcement to swiftly identify and apprehend the suspects involved.

NEXT: Woman Discovers Mysterious 26-Year-Old Check Covering Graveyard Maintenance While Casual Running in Dousman

View More Sports Articles

The DockHounds Opening Weekend Recap

The DockHounds Opening Weekend Recap

The DockHounds' season has officially begun, as of Friday, May 9. The team played their first game of 2025 in Rosemont, Illinois at Impact Field against Illinois rivals the Chicago Dogs. The opening game served as a great start to the year, with the DockHounds...

Why Pickleball Has Become so Popular

Why Pickleball Has Become so Popular

Pickleball, a quirky hybrid of tennis, badminton, and ping-pong, has exploded in popularity over the past decade. From neighborhood courts to professional tournaments, this paddle sport is capturing hearts worldwide. But what’s driving its meteoric rise? Let’s break...

DockHounds Prepare for Their Own Opening Day

DockHounds Prepare for Their Own Opening Day

Last Thursday, March 27 marked the opening day for Major League Baseball, and on Monday, March 31 Wisconsin's very own Milwaukee Brewers hosted their home opener at American Family Field. Although the Brewers have been off to a brief but bad start so far this season,...

Hulk Hogan Comes to Lake Country on Promo Tour

Hulk Hogan Comes to Lake Country on Promo Tour

Hulk Hogan, the professional wrestler and WWE ambassador, is coming to Lake Country on March 18. Hogan has been touring the country promoting his new Real American Beer. The new line of light beer is proudly brewed in the United States and is a partner of the WWE....